What happened to musical.ly, the app that came before TikTok?
musical.ly was the short-video app that became part of TikTok. Its founders built it after giving up on an education app. It reached No. 1 on the US App Store, sold to ByteDance and lost its name in a merger, while the videos people had posted kept running inside another app. The thread running through all of it is cost. The first app needed videos that were expensive to make. The second asked for 15 seconds and a song, and that is when people started making things for it.
The first app cost too much to make
Before musical.ly, Alex Zhu and his partner spent six months building an app for five-minute educational videos, then gave it up. According to KrASIA, the app failed because educational clips were expensive to produce.
A five-minute lesson needs a topic, a script and someone who knows the subject well enough to teach it. Then it has to be filmed and edited. An app built on those videos can only grow as fast as someone can produce them, and every new lesson adds to the bill. A viewer can get through a lesson in five minutes. Making the next one takes far longer. The supply of content was the bottleneck, and money was what kept it moving.
Six months is a long time to spend on an idea that doesn't work. What the founders did next suggests they took the right thing from it. They kept short video and dropped the expensive part. Read in that order, the second app looks like a direct answer to the first app's problem.
A train ride and a second-choice name
Zhu has said musical.ly started with a train ride next to a group of teenagers in California. Published accounts of that ride are short on detail, so it is better left as he tells it. Where he puts the starting point still stands out. The reported story of the education app is about a product and what it cost to make. Zhu's story of the second app starts with a group of teenagers on a train.
The name was a fallback. The founders wanted Music.ly, but according to KrASIA that domain was already taken, so they settled on Musical.ly. The second choice is the one that stuck.
Fifteen seconds and a song
The new app let people make and share homemade music videos of up to 15 seconds. That limit set the size of the job. A clip that short needs no script, no expert and no editing suite. Someone with a phone and a track they liked had everything required, and could make another one straight after.
Set beside the education app, the change is plain. The first product asked for five-minute videos that cost real money to make. The second asked for 15 seconds of someone mucking around to a song. The founders moved from a format they had to pay to supply to one their users could supply themselves, as often as they liked. Growth stopped depending on how many lessons a small team could afford.
musical.ly also had duets, where one person's video played alongside another's. The feature survives in TikTok, where Duet places a user's video side by side with another user's content. A duet gives people a reason to make a video in reply to someone else's. One clip can lead to more clips, and the app doesn't have to commission any of them.
Top of the US App Store, then 200 million downloads
Digiday, writing the following year, reported that musical.ly had hit the top spot on the US App Store "last July". The reasons behind that climb are harder to confirm than the result, so the plain version is the one to keep: an app built on homemade 15-second music videos reached No. 1 in the US.
By mid-2017, the app had been downloaded more than 200 million times in three years. That figure counts downloads. It is easy to read it as a user count, and it shouldn't be. One person can install an app more than once, and a download says nothing about whether someone kept opening it a month later.
Read carefully, the number still says something useful. That many installs in three years means a very large number of people were willing to try an app whose whole offer was a short clip and a song. How many of them stayed is a separate question the figure can't answer.
Sold in 2017, merged into TikTok in 2018
ByteDance bought musical.ly for about USD 1 billion in cash and stock. ByteDance completed the acquisition in 2017, the year before the two apps were combined.
In August 2018, TikTok and musical.ly merged. For users, the switch was mostly a change of app. They could find their account, videos and settings inside the new TikTok app. The name on the icon changed. Nobody had to rebuild a profile or upload old clips again to keep going, so the people who had been posting on musical.ly could carry on where they were.
What musical.ly left in TikTok
Some of musical.ly is still easy to spot. The duet is the clearest piece, along with the habit of making a video in reply to someone else's. The 15-second limit did not last. As of 2025, TikTok allows uploads of up to 60 minutes and in-app recordings of up to 10 minutes. TikTok kept the habits musical.ly built and let the original limit go once those habits were in place.
Perspectism's reading of this history is that musical.ly found its footing when making a post became cheap. The education app depended on content that was expensive to produce. The music app depended on content anyone could make with a phone in the time it takes to play a chorus. What the founders were short of was a format people would happily make for free.
For anyone publishing now, the useful questions come before the content gets made. What are people already coming to you for? What does this format ask of the person making it, and what does it ask of the person watching? A five-minute explainer and a 15-second clip can carry related ideas, but they take very different amounts of work and suit different places. musical.ly's founders found that out by building the expensive version first. Working out which one a piece needs to be before building it saves making the heavy version when the light one would have done the job.
Frequently asked questions
What was musical.ly?
A short-video app where people made and shared homemade music videos of up to 15 seconds. It merged with TikTok in August 2018.
Who bought musical.ly, and when?
ByteDance bought it for about USD 1 billion in cash and stock. The acquisition was completed in 2017, the year before the merger with TikTok.
What happened to musical.ly accounts after the merger?
They moved into TikTok. Users found their account, videos and settings inside the new app.